HB 171: A Direct Attack on Equity and Opportunity

House Bill 171 is a blatantly unconstitutional piece of legislation that undermines the principles of justice, fairness, and opportunity that our laws are meant to uphold. This bill directly conflicts with existing protections designed to ensure that all individuals—regardless of identity or background—have access to the resources and opportunities they need to succeed.

Why Diversity, Equity and Inclusion (DEI) Matters

DEI programs and policies are not just ethical imperatives—they are legal necessities. These initiatives cover a wide range of fundamental protections, including:

• Safeguarding individuals from workplace harassment
• Ensuring pay equity and transparency
• Providing accommodations for individuals with disabilities
• Guaranteeing job security for new parents

When individual needs are met in a fair and just manner, employees thrive, workplaces are more productive, and society as a whole benefits. Yet, HB 171 seeks to dismantle these critical protections under the false pretense of prioritizing ‘merit’ over ‘equity.’

The False Dichotomy Between Merit and Equity

One of the most misleading narratives promoted by supporters of HB 171 is the idea that DEI and merit-based systems are inherently at odds. In reality, they are deeply interconnected. A so-called ‘pure meritocracy,’ as defined by this bill’s sponsors, would do nothing more than maintain the existing status quo, where structural inequalities persist and those who have historically held power continue to benefit the most.

Consider this: White households hold approximately 80% of the wealth in the United States. Without equitable opportunities, a meritocratic system only reinforces these disparities rather than addressing them. True meritocracy cannot exist without ensuring that everyone has a fair chance to compete.

A Call to Action

Advance Carolina and the North Carolina Black and Brown Policy Network strongly oppose HB 171, as it is fundamentally at odds with our core values. We refuse to stand by while policies are introduced that stifle diversity, limit opportunity, and prevent qualified individuals from contributing their skills and perspectives to our communities.

We urge all concerned citizens to speak out against this dangerous bill and contact their representatives. The future of a fair and just society depends on our collective commitment to equity, inclusion and opportunity for all.